Survivor ProspectsSurvivor Prospects

Mission: To determine the top-50 prospects in baseball.
Participants: BDBL owners
Method: Every three days, five prospects are voted "off the island" by our panel of experts.  Prospects are ranked in terms of the number of votes they received.  Participants choose five prospects in the order they feel they deserve to be kicked off the island.  1-5 points are assigned to each ranking, and the voting is tallied every three days.  Ties are decided by the number of prior points accumulated.  The five players with the five highest point totals are eliminated.  The first two votes determine which players belong in the top-50.  Final results will be announced in the next "From the Desk of the Commish."

FINAL RESULTS:

Comparison of BDBL Top 50 to other "experts" (StrikeThree.com, Baseball Prospectus, The Prospect Report, Baseball America and TeamOne Baseball):

Player Team BDBL Strike3 BBP TPR BBA TOB
M.Teixeira SAL 1 1 1 1 1 3
J.Mauer STM 2 20 9 4 4 63
V.Martinez CHI 3 13 4 7 16 18
H.Matsui GIL 4 N/A 2 N/A 8 1
M.Cuddyer NMB 5 4 15 12 17 21
B.Phillips STM 6 3 6 9 7 4
J.Reyes SCS 7 6 3 11 3 8
Kotchman SAL 8 10 27 8 13 59
H.Choi CHI 9 11 7 52 22 33
T.Hafner AKR 10 75 20 27 46 35
J.Foppert ALN 11 5 13 3 5 5
J.Borchard MAN 12 2 22 24 28 30
G.Floyd KAN 13 32 N/L 10 9 92
Fr.Rodriguez OAK 14 18 21 5 10 7
R.Harden AKR 15 36 12 22 29 25
R.Soriano SCS 16 19 N/L 21 27 14
A.Gonzalez GIL 17 33 24 37 31 20
C.Snelling SAL 18 16 10 43 39 29
M.Byrd MAR 19 8 14 57 63 11
J.Stokes SCS 20 50 11 13 15 N/L
K.Ainsworth LIT 21 21 19 25 64 61
S.Kazmir MAN 22 24 N/L 2 11 84
J.Mathis MAR 23 62 N/L 20 48 93
D.Brazelton OAK 24 48 N/L 39 74 10
A.Wainwright VIL 25 14 N/L 35 18 31
J.Morneau GLS 26 9 30 23 14 13
J.Contreras SCA 27 N/A 5 N/A 6 6
J.Williams LIT 28 7 8 29 50 19
J.Bonderman CHI 29 46 N/L 18 20 54
M.Cabrera MAN 30 25 29 19 12 N/L
A.Heilman LIT 31 37 17 78 45 15
J.Arnold ATL 32 N/L 25 80 97 23
S.Choo STM 33 23 16 77 61 N/L
C.Nageotte STM 34 28 35 28 76 N/L
S.Hairston KAN 35 70 23 15 26 64
S.Drew AKR 36 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
M.Restovich OAK 37 51 N/L 73 37 16
T.Linden OAK 38 27 N/L 40 82 68
G.Sizemore LIT 39 26 N/L 64 N/L N/L
A.Sisco SCS 40 44 N/L N/L 53 73
R.Weeks LAU 41 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
L.Nix BCJ 42 35 N/L 41 85 22
A.Marte ALN 43 22 N/L 36 40 N/L
K.Sleeth LAU 44 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
B.Upton SAL 45 93 N/L 17 21 83
C.Lee AKR 46 12 32 45 30 26
R.Baldelli ALN 47 17 28 6 2 2
J.Huber SCS 48 29 34 79 66 N/L
Br.Nelson MAR 49 30 N/L 44 23 N/L
B.Sullivan LAU 50 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A