On
November 21st,
1998, Tony DeCastro -- a
27-year-old
intern architect
from Greenville,
South Carolina
-- became the
sixth member of
the Big Daddy
Baseball League.
A decade later,
DeCastro was one
of only six
original
founding members
of the league
still running
his franchise.
That franchise,
the South
Carolina Sea
Cats, drew the
13th pick in the
inaugural draft.
DeCastro's
strategy in that
draft was to
create a
well-balanced
team in terms of
offense and
pitching.
With his first
pick in the
draft, DeCastro
selected
33-year-old
lefty ace Tom
Glavine.
Glavine enjoyed
an outstanding
year in BDBL,
winning the Eck
League's first
Cy Young award with a 24-4
overall record,
and an ERA of
2.61.
With his next
seven picks,
DeCastro
alternated
between
selecting
pitchers and
hitters.
35-year-old
veteran
shortstop Barry
Larkin
(.292/.366/.468
with 104 R and
104.4 RC) was
DeCastro's
second pick.
Dustin Hermanson
(14-8, 4.01 ERA
in 186+ IP), a
promising young
pitcher at age
26, was the
team's third
pick.
Derek Bell
(.282/.348/.405
with 93.4 RC),
Kerry Ligtenberg
(68+ IP, 3.44
ERA in relief),
Tom Goodwin
(.283/.350/.320),
Jeff Fassero
(10-11, 3.77 ERA
in 205+ IP) and
Henry Rodriguez
(.248/.317/.519
with 30 HR)
followed.
All were between
the ages of
28-36.
DeCastro
continued to
fill the holes
in his active
roster with
veteran players
before turning
his attention to
younger players
(Homer Bush,
Rich Garces,
Mike Frank)
toward the end
of the draft.
In the first
From the Desk of
the Commish
article of the
1999 season, the
Sea Cats were
picked to win
their division.
After a 13-12
showing in the
first chapter,
South Carolina
found themselves
trailing the
division leaders
by two games in
the Petralli
Division.
The following
chapter,
however, the
team collapsed,
going just
11-20. And
by the all-star
break, the Sea
Cats were
looking at a
nine-game
deficit in the
division and a
last-place
record of 33-47.
DeCastro
turned his
attention toward
the 2000 season
at that point,
and
agreed to his
first BDBL
trade at the
Chapter Four
deadline, sending
the team's
greatest asset, Glavine, to the
Slyme in
exchange for
young slugger
Jeremy Giambi.
The trade was a
total bust for
the Sea Cats, as
Giambi was
released
following the
2000 season,
while Glavine
won the EL Cy
Young award and
carried the
Slyme to an Eck
League title.
DeCastro made
two more trades
before the end
of the season,
swapping Homer
Bush and Graeme
Lloyd for Ron
Coomer, Miguel
Batista and Sean
Lowe.
Coomer played
one season for
the 'Cats,
hitting
.258/.303/.449.
Batista also
played just one
season under
contract, going
7-8 with a 3.57
ERA in 136+
innings in 2000.
And Lowe was an
effective (3.42
ERA in 71 IP)
middle reliever
in 2000.
The Sea Cats
wrapped up the
1999 season with
a record of
73-87 -- 13
games out of
first place.
But there was
reason for
optimism heading
into the 2000
season, as DeCastro's 1999
farm draft was
remarkable for
having developed
three low-cost
impact players
in only one
year.
Second round
pick Freddy
Garcia tossed
over 200 innings
(207.2) and
compiled an ERA
of 3.95.
At just 24 years
of age and with
a minimum-wage
salary, Garcia
was considered
to be among the
top young
pitchers in the
game.
Third-round farm pick
Warren Morris
was the team's
full-time second
baseman in 2000 (but hit
a disappointing
.229/.312/.329.)
And DeCastro's
fifth and final
farm pick from
1999, Billy
Koch, served as
the team's
closer in 2000. In
59+ innings,
Koch posted a
6-6 record with
a 4.10 ERA in BDBL 2000.
In addition to
those three rookies,
the Sea Cats
were also
excited to add
Ray Lankford to
the lineup.
Lankford, a
left-handed
power hitter,
was considered
to be a perfect
fit for South
Carolina's home
ballpark,
modeled after
lefty-friendly Yankee Stadium.
In just 419
at-bats,
Lankford hit
.294/.389/.477
for the Sea
Cats, with 80.8
runs created.
With a
left-heavy
lineup and a
solid starting
rotation and
bullpen, the Sea
Cats were picked
to finish in
third place once
again in the
newly-renamed
Person Division.
However, this
prediction was
more a function
of playing in a
very tough
division rather
than any glaring
deficiency on
the Sea Cats.
South Carolina
slumped out of
the gate by
going 7-17 in
Chapter One.
The problem was
the offense,
which scored a
BDBL-low 92 runs
in the chapter,
and hit just
.262/.325/.386
overall.
Lankford
(.231/.295/.308),
in particular,
fell into a
nasty slump
early in the
season, causing
much of
DeCastro's
heartburn.
The team
continued to
slump in Chapter
Two, going 8-16
while scoring a
league-low 104
runs. And
in Chapter
Three, the team
proved their
slow start was
no fluke, as
they went 10-16
and scored just
98 runs.
At the final
trading deadline
of the season,
DeCastro began
reloading for
the 2001 season.
On July 15th,
he made
what he termed
to be a "bold
move" by trading
his team's
franchise
pitcher, Garcia,
along with
Hermanson, in
exchange for
highly-touted pitching
prospect Carl Pavano.
"That one
really is a
gamble,"
explained [DeCastro.]
"We felt
tied down by
Hermanson's
contract.
We really
like Dustin,
but he's
been kind of
a roller
coaster the
last two
years.
When he's at
his lows,
it's hard to
justify
paying him
the kind of
money we
were.
There's no
doubt that
he has the
talent to be
a top-line
starter...Garcia
is very
tough to let
go, but we
really have
high
expectations
for Pavano.
So,
hopefully
his arm will
hold up and
both of us
(the Sea
Cats and
Phoenix
Predators)
can benefit
from this
trade."
Pavano was
ranked the #9
prospect in
baseball by
Baseball America
in 1998.
In 2000, he
posted a 3.06
ERA in 97
innings in the
big leagues, and
looked to be one
of the brightest
young pitchers
in the game at
age 24.
But he followed
that season with
a disastrous,
injury-riddled
year (6.33 ERA
in only 42+ IP),
and never
reached his
lofty potential.
That same day,
DeCastro
announced
another deal,
whereby he sent
his young
closer, Koch, to
the Kentucky Fox
(along with
three others,
including Henry
Rodriguez.)
In exchange, he
received
veteran
all-star Mike
Sweeney (along
with
free-agent-to-be
Robb Nen.)
With two years
remaining on his
contract, at a
combined salary
of only $7
million, Sweeney
enjoyed two
outstanding
seasons for
South Carolina,
hitting
.293/.375/.454
with 112.8 RC in
2001, and
.318/.367/.601
with 45 homers
and a
career-high
135.5 RC in
2002.
South Carolina
wrapped up the
2000 season with
a 62-98 record
-- tied for the
second-worst
record in the
BDBL.
Fortunately for DeCastro, that
record gave him
the second
overall pick in
every round of
the 2001 draft.
And after
trading his #2
and #6 picks to
the Manchester
Irish Rebels in
exchange for
Manchester's #1
pick, the Sea
Cats now owned
two of the top
three picks in
the draft.
The 2001 draft
class included
three dominant
aces in Al
Leiter, Tom
Glavine and
Roger Clemens.
After the Perth
Breeze selected
Leiter with the
#1 pick in the
draft, DeCastro
happily selected
Glavine and
Clemens with the
next two picks.
That season,
Glavine went
20-6 with a 2.70
ERA in 253+
innings, while
Clemens went
18-7 with a 3.18
ERA in 218+
innings.
Those two draft
picks
immediately
propelled the
Sea Cats from an
also-ran to a
bona-fide
contender.
In addition to
those two impact
starting
pitchers, the
Sea Cats also
welcomed back
the impact
bat of Jim
Edmonds.
Edmonds was a
second-round
pick by DeCastro
in the 2000
draft.
Coming off an
injury-plagued
season, DeCastro
took a $5
million gamble
that Edmonds
would bounce
back into form,
and bounce he
did. In
2001, Edmonds
hit
.286/.413/.594
for the Sea
Cats, with a
career-high 49
home runs, 120
runs scored, 120
RBIs, 123 walks
and 148.7 runs
created.
With his two
aces and two
MVP-caliber
hitters (Edmonds
and Sweeney)
serving as the
foundation of
the team,
DeCastro's Sea
Cats were picked
to win the
Person Division.
Once again,
however, the Sea
Cats got off to
a slow start,
going just 14-14
in Chapter One.
Fortunately,
every other team
in the division
got off to an
even slower
start, as the
'Cats finished
the chapter with
a three-game
lead over the
11-17 Villanova
Mustangs.
South Carolina
followed that
chapter by going
15-11 in Chapter
Two and 17-9 in
Chapter Three.
At the all-star
break, DeCastro
added another
slugger to his
lineup in Paul
Konerko. A
free agent at
the end of the
season, Konerko
hit
.293/.353/.414
for the Sea Cats
down the
stretch.
The cost: Scott
Brosius -- a
35-year-old
third baseman
who hit
.321/.365/.421
in only 140
at-bats in his
final BDBL
season. It
was the final
transaction of
the season for
DeCastro, as the
Sea Cats had
built a
comfortable lead
in the division.
Despite playing
in what was
thought to be a
"tough" division
prior to the
start of the
season, South
Carolina was the
only team to
finish with a
record above
.500 in 2001.
They finished
with a 92-68
record -- 18
games ahead of
the Kentucky
Fox.
The Sea Cats
then took on the
Akron Ryche in
the Eck League
Division Series.
The first game
of that series
was a match-up
between Glavine
and Akron's
longtime ace
Pedro Martinez.
Neither pitcher
earned a
decision,
however, as the
game was
extended into
extra innings.
In the bottom of
the 10th, South
Carolina
reliever Mike
Remlinger issued
a leadoff walk
to pinch hitter
John Vander Wal.
Vander Wal
advanced to
second on a
sacrifice bunt,
and then scored
on a base hit by
Ricky Gutierrez.
Game Two saw
another match-up
of aces, as
Clemens faced
Tim Hudson.
Clemens pitched
brilliantly,
allowing just
two runs (one
earned) on three
hits through
seven innings.
But Hudson was
even better, as
he tossed
six-plus shutout
innings.
The Akron
bullpen then
completed the
shutout, giving
the Ryche a
commanding 2-0
series lead as
the series
shifted to South
Carolina.
The Sea Cats
offense came
alive in the
third game of
the series, as
Sweeney, Edmonds
and pitcher Gil
Heredia each
homered en route
to an 8-2 Sea
Cats win.
Then, with
Glavine taking
the hill on
three days of
rest against
Akron's #4
starter Jarrod
Washburn, the
Sea Cats tied up
the series with
a convincing
10-4 win.
But in Game
Five, DeCastro
handed the ball
to his own #4
starter, Mark
Redman, against
the EL's Cy
Young award
winner,
Martinez.
The results were
predictably
disastrous.
During the
regular season,
Redman had
posted an ugly
ERA of 5.72 in
154+ innings.
In Game Five,
Redman was
smacked around
for seven runs
on eleven hits
through six-plus
innings.
In Game Six,
Hudson once
again took the
hill for Akron
against Clemens.
Once again, both
pitchers pitched
well enough to
win. But
in the bottom of
the seventh
inning, Akron
third baseman
Adrian Beltre
turned on
Clemens' 124th
pitch of the
game and
deposited it
into the seats,
giving Akron a
2-1 lead.
Mark Wohlers and
Trevor Hoffman
then nailed down
the eighth and
ninth innings to
give Akron the
series win.
That winter,
DeCastro took an
inventory of his
team and made
the
controversial
decision to
rebuild in 2002
rather than
contend.
Making this
decision more
controversial
was his choice
of trading
partner: Paul Marazita of the
Stamford Zoots.
Before Marazita
had wrapped up
his third
straight BDBL
championship in
2001,
he announced
that he'd added
Clemens from the
Sea Cats.
The Zoots had
lost one of
their three aces
(Randy Johnson)
to free agency
that winter, but
the acquisition
of the reigning
American League
Cy Young helped
to fill that
void
immediately.
In exchange for
his dominant ace,
DeCastro
received a pair
of promising
youngsters in
return: Nick
Johnson and D'Angelo
Jimenez.
The key to the
deal was
Johnson, who was
ranked as the
#13 prospect in
baseball by
Baseball America
the following
spring. In
eight seasons
with the Sea
Cats, Johnson
hit
.289/.403/.479,
but averaged
just 236 at-bats
per season, as
he suffered
through numerous
injuries.
Jimenez played
four seasons for
the Sea Cats,
and hit
.284/.370/.407.
His best season
came in 2005,
when he hit
.333/.425/.476
with 43 doubles
and 126.8 runs
created.
But just two
years later, he
was out of
baseball for
good.
In addition to
Clemens,
DeCastro also
threw in
Edmonds, who hit
.307/.431/.546
for Stamford in
2002, with 131.9
runs created, at
a salary of just
$6 million.
To many, it
seemed a very
steep price to
pay for two
prospects, and
it sealed South
Carolina's fate
for the next two
seasons, as both
Clemens and
Edmonds proved
difficult to
replace.
With Clemens and
Edmonds gone,
DeCastro turned his
attention to
offloading
Sweeney.
In the final
year of his
contract, and
with a salary of
only $4 million,
Sweeney would
hit
.318/.367/.601
in 2002, with 45
home runs and
135.5 runs
created -- both
career highs.
But just prior
to
Opening Day, he
was dealt to
the Kansas Law
Dogs in
exchange for
Shane Halter and
Antonio Perez.
Halter enjoyed a
big season for
the Sea Cats in
'02, hitting
.307/.355/.542
with 97.7 RC,
but he was a
free agent at
the end of the
season.
Perez never
played a game
for the Sea
Cats, and
compiled just
323 at-bats in
his BDBL career.
When his team
got off to another
slow start to
the season (10-18), DeCastro's purge
continued with
the Chapter One trade of
Charles Johnson
to the Zoots in
exchange for
Nate Cornejo and
Chad Krueter.
Cornejo pitched
just 146 innings
in his BDBL
career, with a
record of 6-10
and an ERA of
5.71.
Krueter -- a
37-year-old
backup catcher
-- played just
one season for
South Carolina
(hitting
.145/.288/.345),
and was out of
baseball by the
2004 BDBL
season.
The following
chapter,
DeCastro dealt
away another
impact player in Glavine.
In exchange, he
received young
pitchers Eric
Hiljus and
Rafael Soriano
from the Los
Altos
Undertakers.
While Hiljus
never pitched in
the BDBL again
following the
2002 season,
Soriano gave the
team one
season of
quality relief
pitching in 2004
(57 IP, 43 H, 19
BB, 78 K, 2.37
ERA.)
At the Chapter
Four deadline,
DeCastro shed
yet another
impact player
when he traded
Ray Lankford to
the Madison
Fighting Mimes,
getting Joe
Beimel in
exchange.
Beimel pitched
only one season
for South
Carolina, and
posted an ERA of
7.88 in 64
innings.
Finally, at the
final trading
deadline of the
season, DeCastro
and Marazita
hooked up one
more time, with
Todd Walker
going to
Stamford in
exchange for
Michael Young.
This trade looks
very good for
South Carolina
in retrospect,
as Young became
an impact middle
infielder just
two years later.
However,
DeCastro made
the fatal error
of signing Young
for just one
season following
the 2002 BDBL
season.
As a result, Young hit just
.239/.286/.345
in his only
season in South
Carolina.
Over the next
three seasons,
however, Young
would create
97.3, 107.3 and
120.9 runs.
2002 was a
disastrous
season for
DeCastro and the
Sea Cats in more
ways than one.
A year after
capturing the
division title,
South Carolina
finished in last
place with a
record of 66-94.
DeCastro traded
no fewer than
seven impact
players
throughout the
season, yet
received very
little value
for the 2003
team -- nor any
future Sea Cats
team.
Perhaps the
primary
motivating
factor for
DeCastro's
massive player
purge in 2002
was a major
change to the
rulebook
instituted that
summer. In
an unprecedented
mid-season vote,
the league
agreed nearly
unanimously to
adopt an auction
system for the
top 50 free
agents. No
longer could a
team build a
contender simply
by tanking a
season,
finishing with
90+ losses, and
gaining the
advantage of
having a high
draft pick in
every round of
the draft.
From 2003
forward, the top
free agents
would go to the
teams willing to
spend the money
to acquire them.
And after
shedding tens of
millions in
2002, no team
was in a better
position to
spend money in
the BDBL's first
free agent draft
than DeCastro.
That winter, the
Sea Cats had a
whopping $56.9
million to spend
on 16 players --
a figure that is
still a BDBL
record as of
this writing.
South Carolina's
spending cash
was nearly $19
million higher
than the next
highest team's total. DeCastro spent
$42 million of
that windfall on
six players:
Vladimir
Guerrero ($16M),
Mark Kotsay
($6M), Herbert
Perry ($2.5M),
Andy Pettitte
($8.5M), Darren
Holmes ($4M) and
Tom Glavine
($11.5M.)
In addition to
those free
agents, he
also acquired
Wade Miller
(6-16, 4.55 ERA
in 172+ IP in
2003) from the
Allentown
Ridgebacks that
winter,
sacrificing Ryan Klesko
(.287/.388/.531,
110.9 RC) in
exchange.
And with Miller,
Glavine and
Pettitte
fronting the
rotation, and
Guerrero hitting
in the middle of
the lineup,
surrounded by an
array of platoon
players, the Sea
Cats were once
again predicted
to finish in
first place in
the division.
But once again,
the Sea Cats got
off to a
disappointing
start, going
14-14 in Chapter
One, while
falling four
games behind in
the standings.
It only got
worse from
there, as the
team then went
10-16 in Chapter
Two and 7-19 in
Chapter Three.
By Chapter Four, DeCastro began
selling off some
of his role
players,
including
relievers Darren
Holmes and Steve
Reed, and
utility players
Denny Hocking
and Todd Greene.
In exchange for
Reed, DeCastro
received top
prospect
Lastings
Milledge from
the Salem
Cowtippers.
By 2006,
Milledge would
be the team's
top prospect
(and the 11th
best prospect in
baseball
according to the
BDBL's annual
farm survey.)
Incredibly,
those would be
the only trades
DeCastro would
make in 2003, as
the team was
simply left to
perish.
Despite the
lofty
expectations
that followed
DeCastro's
winter spending
spree, the Sea
Cats finished
with a record of
63-97 -- three
games worse than
the team's
disastrous 2002
season.
After spending
so much money on
the free agent
class of 2002,
DeCastro was
forced to be a
bit more frugal
in the winter of
2003. He
managed to shed
$6 million in
salary by
trading Guerrero
to the Chicago
Black Sox in
exchange for
Andruw Jones.
The trade worked
out fairly well
for South
Carolina, as
Jones hit
.254/.309/.472
with 34 home
runs and 87.4
runs created.
But that would
be the only
trade of the
winter for
DeCastro.
The team made
just one free
agent signing in
the auction,
committing $5.5
million to Tim
Salmon -- a
risky "Type H"
signing for an
injury-plagued
35-year old.
Salmon performed
poorly in 2004,
batting just
.257/.349/.444,
and then was
limited to just
147 at-bats in
2005 due to
injury.
Several factors
led to increased
optimism among
Sea Cats fans
heading into the
2004 season.
The 2001 farm
draft was an
historic draft
in the BDBL due
to the
incredible
amount of impact
talent available
in that year's
draft class. DeCastro held
the #2 overall
pick in that
draft, but
traded it for
catching
prospect Matt LeCroy.
With his second
round pick, he
selected a
pitcher named
Jovanny Cedeno,
who never made
it to the big
leagues.
But with his
third pick, DeCastro made
perhaps the most
brilliant pick
of the draft,
selecting Hank
Blalock.
By the following
year, Blalock
had climbed all
the way up the
prospect
rankings, and
was ranked the
#2 overall
prospect in
baseball in the
BDBL's annual
farm report.
And by 2004,
Blalock had
become the best
hitter in the
South Carolina
lineup, hitting
.309/.362/.574
with 33 home
runs, 122 RBIs
and 106.1 runs
created -- all
at the tender
young age of 23.
By the end of
the league's
first decade,
Blalock would
stand as the
franchise leader
in runs created.
With the
25-year-old
Johnson
(.348/.469/.533
in 336 AB in
'04) across the
diamond, the Sea
Cats were
thought to have
the greatest
young corner
infield in the
league.
And with a
veteran starting
rotation headed
by Pettitte and
Glavine, and a
strong bullpen
led by Soriano,
the Sea Cats
were picked to
finish in second
place in the
annual
pre-season
preview.
The Sea Cats
offense scored
167 runs in the
first chapter
(second-most in
the EL) en route
to a 15-13
record.
The offense
continued to
score runs in
bunches in the
second chapter,
but
unfortunately,
the South
Carolina
pitching staff
allowed even
more runs to
cross the plate,
and the 'Cats
fell to 13-15.
By the all-star
break, the team
owned a 28-28
record and a
four-game
deficit in the
division despite
outscoring the
opposition by 21
runs.
On June 13th,
the Sea Cats
were stuck in
BDBL limbo --
not quite bad
enough to
justify throwing
in the towel,
but not quite
good enough to
put it all on
the line and "go
for it."
Trailing in the
EL wild card
race by
eight games, DeCastro made
the bold
decision to "go
for it."
After several
weeks of
speculation (and
April Fools
pranks), the
Nashville
Funkadelic
finally put
their ace, Roy
Halladay, on the
block. And
to the surprise
of many,
DeCastro was
named the winner
of that
sweepstakes.
As expected,
however, the
cost was very,
very steep.
In the 2002 farm
draft, DeCastro
had traded away
his first two
picks of the
draft (neither
of which was
used.) His
first pick of
the draft,
therefore, came
in the third
round. And
with that pick,
he made the
brilliant
selection of
Jose Reyes.
Just one year
later, Reyes had
become the #3
prospect in
baseball in the
annual BDBL farm
report.
But in June of
2004, Reyes
became the
latest sacrifice
made by DeCastro
in his quest to
return to the
post-season.
Halladay pitched
just six games
for the Sea
Cats, as South
Carolina went
just 14-14 in
Chapter Four,
and fell 11
games behind in
the wild card
race.
Roughly seven
weeks after Halladay was
acquired by
South Carolina,
he was sent
packing to the
Southern Cal
Slyme. In
exchange,
DeCastro
re-acquired
Koch, and picked
up young starter
Matt Clement as
well. Like
many of DeCastro's
trades during
this era,
however, this
trade did not
work out in
South Carolina's
favor.
Koch pitched
just one more
season, racking
up an ugly 6.31
ERA in 37+
innings before
he was forced
from the game.
And Clement
posted ERAs of
5.05, 5.18 and
6.20 over the
next two
seasons, at
salaries of $5
and $6 million.
He was
eventually
released with a
$3.5 million
penalty at the
end of the 2006
season.
In the end, DeCastro
had traded an
all-star
franchise
shortstop in
exchange for two
pitchers who
would cost his
team more than
they would
benefit it.
South Carolina
finished the
2004 season
exactly where
they were
predicted to
finish: in
second place,
with a record of
76-84.
By 2005, Blalock and
Johnson were
expected to
develop into
mega-superstars.
But instead,
Blalock slumped,
hitting just
.244/.322/.450
for the Sea Cats
in 2005, and
Johnson was
injured yet
again, totaling
just 124
at-bats.
And with five
years remaining
on his contract,
the 28-year-old
Andruw Jones
appeared to be
heading backward
in his
development as
well, hitting just
.263/.333/.476
in 2005, with
178 strikeouts
and only 30 home
runs -- his
lowest total
since 2000.
On the mound,
Clement (7-11,
5.05 ERA in 185+
IP) was now the
team's de facto
"ace."
With Soriano
lost for the
season due to
injury, Juan
Rincon (77+ IP,
2.80 ERA) took
over as the
team's closer.
Despite the
glaring need to
renovate his
roster, DeCastro
was unable to
make any trades
that winter, and
headed into the
auction with
several glaring
holes to fill.
Once again, he
attempted to
fill those holes
through free
agency. He signed
veteran Jeff
Bagwell to a $5
million salary,
catcher Ramon
Hernandez at
$4.5M, Todd
Walker at $3M,
and Kenny Rogers
at $3.5M.
While Hernandez
(.301/.365/.539)
turned out to be
a bargain, and
Walker
(.266/.356/.429)
performed about
as well as
expected, the
Bagwell signing
was a disaster,
as he hit only
.229/.303/.400,
and didn't play
well enough in MLB '05 to
warrant an
extension.
Rogers was even
more of a
disaster in
2005, as he went
7-22 on the
season, and
posted an
outrageous ERA
of 6.67 in over
200 innings.
However, he
turned out to be
an asset in
2006, going 17-5
with a 3.63 ERA
in 213+ innings,
at a salary of
only $3.5
million.
After a 12-16
start to the
season, it
looked to be
another lost
season for the
Sea Cats.
This much was
confirmed by a
10-18 record in
Chapter Two.
At the Chapter
Three deadline,
DeCastro made
his first
transaction of
the season,
sending Mike
Piazza to the
Marlboro
Hammerheads in
exchange for
prospect Ian
Kinsler (and
replacement
catcher Jason
LaRue.)
Kinsler proved
to be a valuable
addition in the
coming years.
He made his
rookie debut in
2007, and hit
.290/.346/.471
with 75.2 runs
created, and
continued to
improve in the
coming years.
That same
chapter,
DeCastro swapped
role players
Wade Miller and
Kevin Mench in
exchange for two
young pitchers:
Gustavo Chacin
and Chuck James.
Chacin proved to
be a low-cost,
valuable member
of the starting
rotation in
2006, winning 15
games in 193+
innings, with an
ERA of 4.19.
The Sea Cats
finished the
2005 season with
a 66-94 record
-- the third
time in four
seasons in which
South Carolina
lost more than
90 games.
But heading into
the 2006 season,
it appeared that
a lot of things
had gone South
Carolina's way.
After failing
miserably as a
free agent
signing in 2005,
Rogers (17-5,
3.63 ERA in 213+
IP) had
unexpectedly
become the
team's ace in
2006.
After four
consecutive
injury-plagued
seasons in which
he failed to top
336 at-bats,
Nick Johnson
finally enjoyed
a full, healthy
season for the
Sea Cats in
2006, hitting
.290/.398/.476.
And Blalock
bounced back
from his
horrendous 2005
season by
hitting
.323/.414/.503
with 106.8 RC in
2006.
But the most
unexpected
performance of
all came from
Andruw Jones.
After several
seasons of
declining
performance,
Jones hit just
.245 with a .305
OBP in 2006.
But his slugging
percentage
jumped all the
way up to .576,
and he hit 61
home runs on the
season, and
drove home 166
runs -- both
figures good
enough to lead
the BDBL.
In the free
agent auction,
DeCastro beefed
up the lineup
even further by
signing slugger
Gary Sheffield
to an $11.5
million salary.
Sheffield was
brilliant for
the Sea Cats,
hitting
.285/.383/.502
with 28 homers,
101 RBIs and
109.3 runs
created.
Yet despite a
solid starting
rotation that
included Rogers,
Chacin and
Clement, and a
powerful lineup
featuring
Johnson,
Blalock, Jones
and Sheffield,
the Sea Cats
were picked to
finish last in
the pre-season
preview, due to
playing in what
was considered
to be a very
tough division.
With
South Carolina
tied atop the
Person Division
(with a 34-22
record)
after two
chapters of
play, however, DeCastro
made the
decision to pull
out all the
stops and "go
for it."
Just as he had
done two years
earlier with the
trade of Jose
Reyes, DeCastro
made the bold
decision to
trade his team's
future to
strengthen his
present.
In a trade with
the Great Lakes
Sphinx, DeCastro
acquired ace
pitcher Andy
Pettitte, who
was brilliant
(12-4, 2.28 ERA
in 154+ innings)
down the
stretch.
To add that
much-needed ace,
DeCastro
sacrificed
several young
prospects,
including
Lastings
Milledge and
Josh Barfield.
He also
sacrificed his
second-round
pick from the
2006 free agent
draft, Curt
Schilling, who
went 13-11 with
a 3.41 ERA in
222 innings in
2007, at a
salary of just
$5 million.
That same
chapter,
DeCastro added a
second ace
pitcher in Kevin
Millwood, and a
valuable setup
man in Scott
Shields.
Millwood was
expected to be
an ace for the
Sea Cats, but
instead went
just 8-7 with a
5.65 ERA in 121
innings.
Shockingly,
Shields (3-5,
5.59 ERA)
performed just
as poorly.
In exchange for
those two
pitchers,
DeCastro parted
with a package
of six players,
including young
pitchers Scott
Baker and Jon
Lester, and
highly-touted
prospect
Fernando
Martinez.
Those would be
the final trades
of the season
for DeCastro, as
the Sea Cats
cruised down the
stretch with a
52-28 record in
the second half
-- tied with the
Villanova
Mustangs as the
best record in
the BDBL.
The Sea Cats
jumped out to a
15-5 record in
the final
chapter, and by
the first week
of October they
had captured a
share of first
place in the
Person Division.
South Carolina
wrapped up its
season early,
finishing with a
franchise-best
record of 97-63
with two weeks
left to play in
the season.
It was then a
matter of
waiting for the
Slyme to wrap up
their season.
With a dozen
games remaining
for Southern
Cal, they needed
to go just 7-5
to tie for the
division lead.
But instead, the
Slyme had to
settle for the
Eck League wild
card, as they
went just 5-7
over those final
twelve games to
finish the
season two games
behind the Sea
Cats.
The last time
the Sea Cats
appeared in the
post-season,
their Division
Series opponents
were the Akron
Ryche. In
2006, South
Carolina got the
rematch they
wanted.
Coincidentally
enough, the 2006
series began the
same way as the
2001 series,
with Akron ace
Pedro Martinez
facing off
against South
Carolina's ace
and neither
pitcher getting
the decision as
the game
extended into
extra innings.
This time, #8
hitter Tony
Graffanino led
off the top of
the 12th inning
with a base hit,
advanced to
second on a
sacrifice bunt,
and scored on a
single by Omar
Vizquel.
Juan Rincon then
closed out the
bottom of the
12th to give the
Sea Cats the
series
advantage.
In Game Two,
Millwood -- who
had been such a
disappointment
during the
regular season
-- redeemed
himself by pitching a
gem, striking
out ten batters
in six innings
while
surrendering
just two runs.
South Carolina
then tacked on
four runs over
the final two
innings to turn
a 3-2 nailbiter
into a
comfortable 7-2
win.
When the series
shifted to South
Carolina for
Game Three, the
Sea Cats
threatened to
make short work
of the Ryche by
taking a 3-2
lead into the
ninth inning.
But Akron then
rallied for four
runs in the
ninth off of
Rincon to win by
a score of 6-4.
The two rivals
then played yet
another
extra-inning
game in Game
Four -- this
time extending
the game to 15
innings.
Akron scored a
run in the top
of the 15th to
take an 11-10
lead, but the
Sea Cats refused
to quit.
With the bottom
third of their
lineup stepping
to the plate,
they put two
runners on base
with one out.
Luis Castillo
(who had also
been acquired
along with
Millwood and
Shields earlier
in the year)
then laced a
triple to the
gap to score
both the
game-tying and
game-winning
runs.
Akron -- led by
their stopper,
Martinez -- then
battled back to
win Game Five by
a score of 5-3,
forcing the
series to return
to Akron.
And for the
third time in
the series, the
two teams needed
more than nine
innings to
determine the
winner.
South Carolina
carried a 4-2
lead into the
ninth inning of
Game Six, but a
two-run homer by
Akron catcher
Jason Varitek
off of Rincon
tied the game in
the bottom of
the ninth.
In the 10th,
Sheffield led
off the inning
with a base hit,
and stole his
way into scoring
position.
Ramon Hernandez
then plated him
with a base hit.
Graffanino then
plated an
insurance run
with a clutch
two-out hit.
And Solomon
Torres closed
out the 10th
inning against
the top of the
Akron lineup to
close out the
series and send
the Sea Cats to
the EL
Championship
Series.
South Carolina's
ELCS opponents
were the
Villanova
Mustangs, who
were the only
team during the
regular season
to win 100 or
more games.
But the Sea Cats
jumped out to a
4-0 lead in the
first inning of
Game One, and
were able to
hold on the rest
of the way,
eking out a 6-5
win. But
the Mustangs won
convincingly in
Game Two by a
score of 8-1,
and then took
the series lead
in Game Three
with a 3-1 win,
as the vaunted
Sea Cats lineup
suddenly stopped
hitting.
Villanova then
jumped out to a
3-1 series lead
with an 8-6 win
in Game Four.
With South
Carolina's backs
up against the
wall, they once
again managed to
win an
extra-innings
game in Game
Five. They
did it in
dramatic
fashion, as they
first tied the
game in the
bottom of the
ninth on a sac
fly by Nick
Johnson, and
then won it in
the bottom of
the tenth on
another sac fly.
Then, in Game
Six, the Sea
Cats played an
extra-innings
playoff game for
the fifth time
in the 2006
post-season.
With the game
tied at 1-1 in
the bottom of
the 10th,
DeCastro turned
once again to
Rincon. A
pair of singles
and a wild pitch
put two runners
in scoring
position with
one out.
Pinch hitter
Casey Kotchman
then grounded a
ball to the
drawn-in South
Carolina
infield, but the
throw home
arrived too
late. The
Sea Cats' season
was done.
All the
money tied up
among Millwood,
Jones and
Sheffield meant
that DeCastro
had very little
money ($10.3
million) to
spend on free
agents in 2007.
Millwood
followed up his
disappointing
BDBL season with
a disappointing
MLB season.
And yet, despite
the significant
decline in
numbers, he
actually
performed far
better (18-12,
3.73 ERA in 239
IP) in the BDBL
than he did in
MLB.
Blalock
(.312/.377/.487)
also performed
far better for
the Sea Cats in
2007 than he did
in MLB.
And Johnson
(.286/.397/.515,
120.3 RC in 567
AB) enjoyed the
healthiest and
most productive
season of his
BDBL career in
the final year
of his four-year
contract.
But Sheffield
missed most of
the season due
to injury, and
racked up just
113 at-bats in
2007, at a
salary of $11.5
million.
Rogers, Pettitte
(traded that
winter for Paul
Lo Duca in a
salary dump) and
Schilling were
all gone,
leaving a
rotation of
Millwood, Clay
Hensley, Chuck
James and
Esteban Loaiza.
It was
considered to be
one of the
weakest
rotations in the
BDBL.
DeCastro sat out
of the auction,
and went into
the season with
a team that was
expected to
finish in last
place in the
division just
months after
making it all
the way to the
ELCS.
Despite the
concerns over
the pitching
staff, the Sea
Cats were a
surprisingly
respectable
39-41 in the
first half of
the season.
Unfortunately,
in a division
that included
two .600 teams
and a 43-37
Slyme team, that
respectable
record was only
good for last
place.
With a dearth of
trade bait,
DeCastro did his
best to get as
much value as he
could for the
players he had.
At the Chapter
Three deadline,
he traded four
players --
including
prospect Adam
Lind -- to the
New Milford
Blazers for
Jarrod Washburn,
David Dellucci
and Brian Backe.
The Sea Cats
went 8-16 in
Chapter Four,
removing any
pretense of
contention.
At the final
trading
deadline,
DeCastro
officially
unfurled the
white flag, and
traded every
valuable player
he could,
including
Jones, Shields, Dellucci,
Hensley and Johnson.
In exchange, he
received
prospects
Fernando
Martinez
(re-acquired
from the Chicago
Black Sox) and
Alan Horne, and
"young veterans"
Josh Towers, Gil Meche and Dan
Johnson.
The Sea Cats
wrapped up the
2007 season with
a record of
70-90. In
three seasons,
the Sea Cats had
managed to go
from 90+ losses
to 90+ wins, and
back again to
90+ losses.
The prognosis
for the Sea Cats
heading into the
winter of 2008
were not good.
But with a
dearth of trade
bait, DeCastro
once again sat
on his hands
that winter
without making a
single trade.
His most
valuable trade
asset was Meche,
who enjoyed a
surprisingly
effective MLB
season.
Meche was
eventually dealt
to the Great
Lakes Sphinx,
prior to Opening
Day, in exchange
for Boof Bonser,
Lastings
Milledge, Sean
Gallagher and
Alexei Ramirez.
Just as in 2003,
DeCastro had a
ton of money to
spend on free
agency in 2008,
with $43.9
million (the
second-largest
total in the
league.)
But unlike 2003,
the 2008 free
agent class was
not very strong.
As a result,
DeCastro won the
bidding on just
two low-cost
veterans: Mike
Mussina (at $3M)
and Jason Giambi
($2M.)
With nearly $39
million still
remaining in his
budget, DeCastro
loaded up on
veterans in the
draft, hoping to
buy low on
former stars
like Pedro
Martinez, Shawn
Green, Eric
Chavez and Geoff
Jenkins coming
off down years.
South Carolina
was predicted to
finish in last
place. It
was thought that
the only thing
keeping them
from being the
worst team in
the league was
the presence of
the Atlanta Fire
Ants, who would
finish the
season with a
BDBL record for
losses.
Predictably, the
Sea Cats slumped
out to an 8-20
start in Chapter
One, and
followed that
with a 10-18
Chapter Two.
And despite the
quickly sinking
ship, DeCastro
failed to make a
single trade
throughout the
2008 season, and
picked up only
four free agents
all year.
The Sea Cats
wrapped up the
season with a
record of 62-98.
The Sea Cats
franchise
reached the
80-win mark just
twice in the
league's first
decade.
The first time
this modest goal
was achieved, it
was accomplished
in large part
due to the
acquisition of
two impact free
agents. In
2001, DeCastro
took full
advantage of his
team's high
draft position
(which was the
result of
performing so
poorly in 2000)
to add a pair of
free agent aces
in Tom Glavine
and Roger
Clemens.
Those two aces
won 38 games
combined, and
pitched more
than 472
innings,
carrying South
Carolina to
their first
playoffs
appearance and
division title.
Five years
later, DeCastro
recaptured the
division title a
second time
thanks to the
long-awaited
maturation of
former top farm
prospects Hank
Blalock and Nick
Johnson, a fluke
power season by
Andruw Jones,
and through the
key mid-season
acquisition of
Andy Pettitte.
But when each of
those players
reverted to
their previous
disappointing
form, the
franchise fell
back into the
division cellar.
DeCastro has
much in common
with his Eck
League
counterpart, D.J.
Shepard, whose
franchise was
profiled on this
page last month:
Both DeCastro and Shepard are
founding fathers of the BDBL.
Both owners have avoided the trade
table, compared to other GMs in the league.
Both owners are quiet by nature,
and keep their opinions and strategies closely-guarded.
Both owners value pitching and
hitting equally.
Both owners rely primarily upon
free agency to fill the holes in their rosters.
Yet, despite their similarities in
style, Shepard's Akron Ryche won 162 games more than DeCastro's Sea
Cats over the league's first decade. This, despite the fact
that South Carolina's farm system has ranked far higher than Akron's
in the league's annual Farm Report. From 2000-2009, South
Carolina's farm posted an average rank of 7.9, while Akron's farm
ranked just 13.3 on average.
The problem is that many of South
Carolina's highly-regarded prospects (such as J.R. House, Jason
Stokes, Rafael Soriano, Justin Huber, Josh Barfield, Yusmeiro Petit,
Lastings Milledge and Reid Brignac) never panned out. And
the ones that did (Blalock, Johnson, Reyes, Lester, Kinsler, Baker)
were either injured too often to make much of an impact in South
Carolina, or were traded away before they busted out into stars.
Because DeCastro has been so reluctant to
trade, and because the Sea Cats farm system has produced so few impact
players despite their high ranking in the annual Farm Report, DeCastro
has attempted to fill his team's deficiencies through free agency.
And the problem with free agency is that an owner is forced to pay
market value for the best (often overpriced veteran) players. As a
result, the Sea Cats have enjoyed little success, other than those two
seasons -- one where the worst teams in the league enjoyed the greatest
advantage in signing free agents.
Since the advent of the free agent
auction, there is no longer an advantage to finishing at the bottom of
the standings. And since the free agent draft pool has dried up,
there is no longer an advantage to having a lot of money to spend in the
auction. So, moving forward, the Sea Cats will need to find
another way to build a championship-caliber team.